Skip to main content

No Intermediate-Mass Black Hole for Omega Centauri?

 


From - Sky & Telescope

By - Arielle Frommer

Editted by - Amal Udawatta

Omega Centauri as galactic nucleus
The iconic globular cluster Omega Centauri globular cluster. home to some 10 million stars.
ESO / INAF-VST / OmegaCAM; Acknowledgement: A. Grado, L. Limatola / INAF-Capodimonte Observatory

Last month, astronomers discovered a giant black hole in Omega Centauri. But it might contain a swarm of stellar-mass black holes instead.

A new study has revealed that the Milky Way’s largest globular cluster, where astronomers recently reported the discovery of a central intermediate-mass black hole, may in fact contain thousands of stellar-mass black holes instead.

Around 17,000 light-years away in the constellation Centaurus, Omega Centauri is unique among globular clusters. With its large mass and complex stellar dynamics, astronomers think it originated as an dwarf galaxy that was swallowed by the Milky Way long ago. The discovery of an intermediate-mass black hole (IMBH) at its center was an exciting result, published in Nature, that promised to shed light on black hole evolution in such small galaxies.

However, a recent paper submitted to Astronomy & Astrophysics may temper that excitement. While the team’s findings didn’t rule out the mid-size black hole scenario, they found that Omega Centauri’s mass is better explained by a plethora of stellar-mass black holes swooping in and out of the cluster’s center.

Hidden Remnants

The core of Omega Centauri
This Hubble Space Telescope image shows a portion of Omega Centauri, with stars resolved as individual points of light.
NASA / ESA / Hubble SM4 ERO Team

As the ancient stars of Omega Centauri swirl around its center, their trajectories are affected as the cluster’s central mass tugs on their orbits. Astronomers consider the motion of the cluster’s stellar population, or its stellar kinematics, to make their best guess on the make-up of the cluster’s central mass.

The study, led by Andrés Bañares Hernández (University of La Laguna, Spain), included observations from millions of stars and also accounted for the motion of pulsars — highly magnetized neutron stars that shoot rays of light towards Earth as they whip around on millisecond timescales. They rotate like ultra-precise lighthouses, which enables astronomers to track their movements through the cluster. Those motions affect the timing of when the pulses reach Earth; astronomers measured the pulsars’ accelerations  to estimate the cluster’s central mass.

By observing the movement of both stars and pulsars, the team determined that the center most likely contains a horde of 10,000 to 20,000 stellar-mass black holes — around 200,000 to 300,000 solar masses’ worth — rather than an intermediate-mass black hole.

The possibility of an IMBH in Omega Centauri still exists: “Our analysis does not rule out an IMBH, but rather sets a limit on its mass,” says team member Francesca Calore (French National Center for Scientific Research). The study predicts an upper limit of 6,000 solar masses for an IMBH, less than what Häberle’s team estimated its mass to be: between 8,200 and 50,000 solar masses.

One reason for this discrepancy is the different escape velocities that the two papers measured for the cluster. Häberle’s group determined that the seven stars’ velocities were higher than the expected escape velocity, so Omega Centauri needed an IMBH to keep those stars bound in orbit. However, Hernández’s study calculated a higher escape velocity for the cluster due to the presence of stellar remnants — like stellar-mass black holes. The mass of these additional, unseen stellar corpses allow the stars to move at high speeds without needing an IMBH to keep them bound.

However, even if an IMBH were present, the two studies estimate different masses for it. The team is therefore interested in including the velocity data from Häberle’s findings in later studies to see if they can reconcile the discrepancy.

Ancient Galaxy or Not?

The stakes for finding an IMBH in Omega Centauri are nothing less than the nature and origin of this cluster. If Omega Centauri is in fact the remnant core of a dwarf galaxy that started orbiting the Milky Way around 9 billion years ago, an IMBH is expected and would provide a unique window into black hole formation.

Entering orbit would have stripped stars from the dwarf’s outskirts, whittling the galaxy down to something resembling a globular cluster. Entry would also have “stopped the growth of its central black hole and kept it in an evolutionary state rather close to its initial mass,” says Nadine Neumayer (also at Max Planck), coauthor on the earlier Nature study. With the black hole’s growth arrested, it would never have grown into the supermassive type typical in most large galaxies. Finding an IMBH is akin to “finding a fossil that tells us about the early evolution of supermassive black holes,” Neumayer adds.

But others disagree, arguing that an IMBH isn’t expected. Gerry Gilmore (University of Cambridge, England), who was also not involved in either study, explained that, given that globulars are full of stars, stellar remnants such as neutron stars and stellar-mass black holes ought to be common. What’s more, as heavier objects, they should “sink” into the center of the cluster. So stellar-mass black holes in Omega Centauri’s core are entirely expected.

At present, the source of Omega Centauri’s central mass remains a mystery. Simon Portegies Zwart (Leiden Observatory, The Netherlands), who was not involved in either study, found the potential discovery of an IMBH “super exciting,” but he also acknowledges that the evidence isn’t quite there yet.

“Extraordinary discoveries require extraordinary proof,” he says. “Regretfully, I do not yet see sufficient proof.” For now, it seems possible that Omega Centauri hosts a swarm of ordinary stellar-mass black holes after all.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Why did Homo sapiens outlast all other human species?

  From - Live Science By  Mindy Weisberger Edited by - Amal Udawatta Reproductions of skulls from a Neanderthal (left), Homo sapiens (middle) and Australopithecus afarensis (right)   (Image credit: WHPics, Paul Campbell, and Attie Gerber via Getty Images; collage by Marilyn Perkins) Modern humans ( Homo sapiens ) are the sole surviving representatives of the  human family tree , but we're the last sentence in an evolutionary story that began approximately 6 million years ago and spawned at least 18 species known collectively as hominins.  There were at least nine  Homo  species — including  H. sapiens  —  distributed around Africa, Europe and Asia by about 300,000 years ago, according to the Smithsonian's  National Museum of Nat ural History  in Washington, D.C. One by one, all except  H. sapiens  disappeared.  Neanderthals  and a  Homo  group known as the  Denisovans  lived alongside...

New Comet SWAN Now Visible in Small Scopes

     From :- Sky & Telescope  By :- Bob King  Edited by :- Amal Udawatta This spectacular image of Comet SWAN (C/2025 F2) was taken on April 6th and shows a bright, condensed coma 5′ across and dual ion tails. The longer one extends for 2° in PA 298° and the other 30′ in PA 303°. Details: 11"/ 2.2 RASA and QHY600 camera. Michael Jaeger Amateur astronomers have done it again — discovered a comet. Not by looking through a telescope but through close study of  publicly released, low-resolution images  taken by the  Solar Wind Anisotropies  (SWAN) camera on the orbiting  Solar and Heliospheric Observatory  (SOHO). On March 29th, Vladimir Bezugly of Ukraine was the first to report a moving object in SWAN photos taken the week prior. Michael Mattiazzo of Victoria, Australia, independently found "a pretty obvious comet" the same day using the same images, noting that the object was about 11th magnitude and appeared to be brightening. R...

The indigenous women saving India's endangered giant yams

  From BBC News   By-  Kamala Thiagarajan   Edited by - Amal Udawatta Sai Krishan, Thirunelly Tribal Special Intervention Programme Lakshmi and Shantha with a species of tuber locally called the Noorang (Credit: Sai Krishan, Thirunelly Tribal Special Intervention Programme) In a tribe in southern India, a group of women are working hard to revive the country's ancient native tubers, and bring them back into everyday culture. Lakshmi spends several hours each day digging out large lumpy and hairy yam tubers, starchy roots that grow below the soil. Some weigh an unwieldy 5kg (11lb) and are 4.5ft-long (1.4m), almost as tall as she is. It's painstaking work, says 58-year-old Lakshmi, who goes by one name. First, she has to cut out the thick shoot above the ground. Then, she uses shovels to dig up the earth around the buried stem and a paddle-like flat chisel to gently pry out the tuber. She uses her hands to dig the tuber out of the ground to avoid damaging its delicate...