Skip to main content

COMET 46P/WIRTANEN: ALL DUST, NO ICE

 

  From-  Sky & Telescope,

  By -  ASS NOVA

 Edited by - Amal Udawatta,

Blue-toned comet image
An image of Halley’s comet.
NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology; CC BY 4.0

Where is all of the water around hyperactive comets coming from? A recent article asked if it could be “Ice, Ice, Maybe?” and concluded that it likely isn’t.

Where is all of the water around hyperactive comets coming from? A recent article asked if it could be “Ice, Ice, Maybe?” and concluded that it likely isn’t.

ICY MYSTERY

Comets spend most of their time far from the Sun, where it’s too cold (too cold) for ices trapped within their cores to sublime into gas. When their travels bring them inwards, though, these frozen materials transform into a gas cloud that escapes and enshrouds the nucleus. At this point, the comet is considered “active,” and though this happens to all comets, the severity of this outgassing varies widely. Some comets only sputter, and not much of their surfaces sublimes away. Others are mysteriously “hyperactive,” meaning they (go to the extreme) and produce so much water gas that it can’t all have come just from the surface layers of the nucleus.

One hypothesis claims that this excess water comes from ice grains near the surface of the nucleus. Though data collected in situ by robotic explorers confirm that these grains exist within at least some comets, these haven’t been observed on any aggressively outgassing objects and have not been conclusively linked to overabundant water.

To address this uncertainty, Theodore Kareta (Lowell Observatory) and a team of researchers (stopped, collaborated, and) observed a strange comet named 46P/Wirtanen in late 2018. Much like an early hip-hop artist, 46P was “hyperactive” in the 1990s and has steadily calmed down since. During its 1996–1997 close approach to the Sun, it threw off enough water that 100% of its surface must have been actively outgassing. By the time 46P came (back for a brand new) apparition in 2018, however, only 58% of its surface was contributing to gas production. Kareta and the team hoped to find icy grains near the core that could explain the earlier exuberance.

The near-infrared spectrum of Comet 46P.
Kareta et al. / Planetary Science Journal 2023

ICE-FREE

When reviewing their near-infrared reflectance spectrum, however, the team did not see the telltale absorption dips caused by water. Instead, the spectrum looked nearly featureless, with a red slope and nothing to indicate the presence of ice (vanilla or otherwise).

The team then went beyond a best-fit model and used a Markov chain Monte Carlo algorithm to put the tightest possible constraints on the amount of ice present. They found that, at most, water ice could make up <0.6% of 46P’s surface — not nearly enough to explain its previous hyperactivity.

simulated comet image with contours
A simulated image of 46P’s coma, oriented to match the viewing geometry of the real observations.
Kareta et al. / Planetary Science Journal 2023

Now the planetary science community is left with a problem: where is all of this water coming from? In principle, JWST could say “(yo I’ll solve it)” and turn its singularly capable suite of instruments on a few outgassing comets. Luckily, with plenty of fuel left and plenty of targets to choose from, we may get an answer in the next few years.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Why did Homo sapiens outlast all other human species?

  From - Live Science By  Mindy Weisberger Edited by - Amal Udawatta Reproductions of skulls from a Neanderthal (left), Homo sapiens (middle) and Australopithecus afarensis (right)   (Image credit: WHPics, Paul Campbell, and Attie Gerber via Getty Images; collage by Marilyn Perkins) Modern humans ( Homo sapiens ) are the sole surviving representatives of the  human family tree , but we're the last sentence in an evolutionary story that began approximately 6 million years ago and spawned at least 18 species known collectively as hominins.  There were at least nine  Homo  species — including  H. sapiens  —  distributed around Africa, Europe and Asia by about 300,000 years ago, according to the Smithsonian's  National Museum of Nat ural History  in Washington, D.C. One by one, all except  H. sapiens  disappeared.  Neanderthals  and a  Homo  group known as the  Denisovans  lived alongside...

New Comet SWAN Now Visible in Small Scopes

     From :- Sky & Telescope  By :- Bob King  Edited by :- Amal Udawatta This spectacular image of Comet SWAN (C/2025 F2) was taken on April 6th and shows a bright, condensed coma 5′ across and dual ion tails. The longer one extends for 2° in PA 298° and the other 30′ in PA 303°. Details: 11"/ 2.2 RASA and QHY600 camera. Michael Jaeger Amateur astronomers have done it again — discovered a comet. Not by looking through a telescope but through close study of  publicly released, low-resolution images  taken by the  Solar Wind Anisotropies  (SWAN) camera on the orbiting  Solar and Heliospheric Observatory  (SOHO). On March 29th, Vladimir Bezugly of Ukraine was the first to report a moving object in SWAN photos taken the week prior. Michael Mattiazzo of Victoria, Australia, independently found "a pretty obvious comet" the same day using the same images, noting that the object was about 11th magnitude and appeared to be brightening. R...

The indigenous women saving India's endangered giant yams

  From BBC News   By-  Kamala Thiagarajan   Edited by - Amal Udawatta Sai Krishan, Thirunelly Tribal Special Intervention Programme Lakshmi and Shantha with a species of tuber locally called the Noorang (Credit: Sai Krishan, Thirunelly Tribal Special Intervention Programme) In a tribe in southern India, a group of women are working hard to revive the country's ancient native tubers, and bring them back into everyday culture. Lakshmi spends several hours each day digging out large lumpy and hairy yam tubers, starchy roots that grow below the soil. Some weigh an unwieldy 5kg (11lb) and are 4.5ft-long (1.4m), almost as tall as she is. It's painstaking work, says 58-year-old Lakshmi, who goes by one name. First, she has to cut out the thick shoot above the ground. Then, she uses shovels to dig up the earth around the buried stem and a paddle-like flat chisel to gently pry out the tuber. She uses her hands to dig the tuber out of the ground to avoid damaging its delicate...